I thought her face looked familiar (and I’m in love).

Viewers have been raving about the pilot of the Max miniseriesThe Penguin.

The cast elevated the first episode to one of the year’s most well-received show openers.

Colin Farrell, heavily made up as the Penguin, in character from the TV series "The Batman," dressed in a suit, gesturing with his hand

So, let’s unmask the cast and see if you recognize them outside of theirPenguinroles.

He’s also been seen as David in the Academy Award-nominated filmThe Lobster.

Cristin Milioti plays Sofia Falcone.

Colin Farrell in a pinstriped suit and tie at a red carpet event

She’s also been seen as Teresa in the filmThe Wolf of Wall Street.

Rhenzy Feliz plays Victor Aguilar.

He was also the voice actor for Camilo inEncanto.

Colin Farrell in a scene from "The Lobster," wearing glasses, a dark blazer, and a blue sweater, seated on a bench with greenery in the background

Deirdre O’Connell plays Francis Cobb.

The Tony Award-winner has also been seen guest-starring in countless TV shows and films, includingDetours.

Clancy Brown plays Salvatore Maroni.

Cristin Milioti at a red carpet event, wearing silver earrings and a sleek, reflective dress

He also voices Mr. Krabs inSpongeBob Squarepants.

Michael Zegen plays Alberto Falcone.

He’s also been seen as Joel Maisel inThe Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.

A woman with curly hair and a floral-patterned outfit engages in a conversation with a man wearing glasses, in a scene from a movie or TV show

Carmen Ejogo plays Eve.

She’s also been seen as Coretta Scott King in the Academy Award-winning filmSelma.

Theo Rossi plays Dr. Julian Rush.

Rhenzy Feliz dressed in a black jacket stands in front of a dark brick wall backdrop, looking at the camera

He’s also been seen as Juan Carlos “Juice” Ortiz inSons of Anarchy.

Michael Kelly plays Johnny Vitti.

He’s also been seen as the Daily Planet’s Steve Lombard inMan of Steel.

Antonio Madrigal smiling and waving by a door, with villagers in the background in a scene from Encanto

And lastly, Mark Strong plays the recast version of Carmine Falcone.

Who’s your favorite character in the show so far?

Comment below and share your thoughts!

Deirdre O'Connell poses in front of a Lifetime backdrop, wearing a floral print dress and a black blazer. She is smiling broadly

Woman with tied-back hair smiling, wearing a lace-style top, in a lively setting with blurred background lights

Clancy Brown in a casual shirt and dark blazer attends a promotional event

Mr. Krabs from SpongeBob SquarePants cheerfully holding a dollar bill between his claw with a blue, underwater backdrop

Michael Zegen on the red carpet in formal attire with a black suit, white shirt, and black tie

Michael Zegen, in mid-20th-century attire, stands pensively by a brick wall in a likely TV or movie scene

Carmen Ejogo poses in an orange patterned outfit at a TV and Movies event

Angelina Johnson standing beside a stained-glass window featuring a colorful religious figure

Benjamin Bratt attends an event. He wears a tailored suit jacket with a plain shirt underneath. The background has a brick wall pattern

A solemn man with a shaved head and a tattoo on his scalp looks off-camera in a somber scene, wearing a button-up shirt

Michael Kelly stands with arms crossed in a long-sleeve shirt at a BUILD series event

The image shows a man named Steve Lombard struggling amidst the rubble, reaching out while looking determined

Mark Strong wears a dark suit and a dotted tie, posing at an event

Actor Mark Strong in character, wearing a dark, formal attire with a serious expression in a scene from a movie