My flabber has been gasted.

Gayle King, you should’ve taken this one to the grave, babe.

“This is what it’s supposed to look like, with creamy egg, custard filling.

Gayle King on the red carpet at a Caring for Women event, wearing an elegant dark strapless dress with a red, flame-like design at the bottom, holding a clutch

Now, this sounds good.”

“So that’s what I ordered,” Gayle added.

“This is what I received.

Gayle King discussing "Pie-gate pt. 2" on set. There is an emoji of a pie with wide eyes

I sent this picture to the company to complain about how it arrived.”

The company said they were mortified."

But the silence didn’t last long, because it was then followed by echoes of “EWW!”

A slice of pie with a flaky crust and creamy filling on a plate, with the whole pie in the background

“I’d been thinking about it for three days,” Gayle confessed.

“I did not think it had been eaten.

I honest to god thought it had been jostled, until I started asking people.”

Gayle King smiling in an animal print dress at an InStyle magazine event

you’ve got the option to watch Gayle recount the tale below.

Watch part two with her best friend, Oprah,here.

Half-eaten slice of pie in a clear plastic container

A slice of half-eaten pie with a flaky crust and creamy filling in a plastic container on a dark surface

Gayle King smiles wearing a sleeveless, multi-colored striped dress at an event

Gayle King in a sleeveless dress and sandals at the premiere of "Divorce in the Black"

Gayle King laughs while sitting on a couch during the filming of CBS This Morning. She is wearing a colorful floral dress and glasses

Gayle King smiles on the red carpet in a floral one-shoulder gown

Gayle King smiles at an event, wearing a form-fitting, long-sleeved dress with a pink and purple tie-dye pattern

Instagram comment by knitreader: "I almost fell off my chair when she said she ate it! Oh Gayle"

Comment from ariannagab: "Knowing Gayle I literally said at the beginning 'I know she still ate it either way'" with a laughing-crying emoji

Comment from @msnessabee: "Now Gayle! If it had been jostled, then where is the jostled part?"

Instagram comment by 7taryn9 reading "Her heart told her mind to hush"

Comment by _shellbsta: "There's no way half the pie jostled away" with three laughing-crying face emojis

A comment by sumarfraz1: "I was sipping on my morning tea and when Nate asked the question and Gayle hesitated I almost choked. I was screaming NO GAYLE NO" with two sick emojis and four crying-laughing emojis